Reviews

I will miss Eva

I think this was a good wrap-up to the series, but not my favorite book. It's pretty long and kind of loses its urgency as it goes on despite the building plot.
I still really enjoyed it and loved it for the characters, there was a lot of good full-circle character moments in this book.
This is a good fantasy series for anyone who really enjoys world-building and magic, with obvious undercurrents of romance, as well.

This whole series is 5 stars for me, I love the characters so much. This had the perfect ending to everyone's story line, and still managed to throw in some twists and turns. I'm sad it's over!

Much better than book 2. However I do think a map and better story-building would have helped make the series feel more cohesive. The concepts in this are interesting, but the way a lot of it played out was confusing and pulled my attention away from the heart of the plot.

I love the characters and overarching story in this trilogy, but this final book was mainly a war book and I don’t love those in these types of fantasies. That being said I enjoyed the villain arc in this and really felt for the characters during parts of this. Overall, it just felt too long with big stretches of not much happening and then quick sequences of action.

this series had no misses. i really did think it was going to rip me to pieces there for a minute but i wouldn’t have it any other way. i don’t have a single clue what im supposed to read after all of that now though.

My babies

So, so very good. I got into a slump in the beginning just because I really did not care for Aefe’s new story. However it does get much, much better. Although Caduan and Aefe were not nearly as dear to me in this book, as they were in the last.

highly recommend.

I loved this series so much, such a beautiful ending! These books really wore me out though, wish there were more happy times, other than that i loved it

This is why I read

I think this series is very misrepresented, namely on TikTok. People say that this book gave them the same feeling as the SJM universe. I would have to disagree. Having just read Mistborn by Brian Sanderson, I would say it closer resembles that with significantly more romance and a little bit of spice. This isn't a series you can coast through, nor is it one that keeps you on the edge of your seat, though it does make a lasting impact. I am sure I will think about this book plenty over the next few months.
What I think is one of the most distinctively attractive aspects of this book is the moral greyness of all of the characters in the book. There is no clear "bad guy" from a reader's perspective, though each narrator clearly has an enemy they deem to be the bad guy. It was so bizarre and refreshing to me was that, through the three main narrators, you were able to see altruistic and loving intentions from all three warring parties. So, while their actions are deplorable, they sit in a grey region as opposed to a traditional black and white, good versus evil.
One thing I did not like was the amnesia troupe for the love interests. Sometimes it feels a little overdone, as if it is just put into a book to create more conflict once the will they/won't they question for a couple has been answered.
As far as closing out the series, I feel like this book did a great job. It was a little long winded at the end, but I think it was good that while there was a happy ending there was also an acknowledgement of the suffering and trauma they experienced.

I’ve struggled with where I wanted to rate this book and I think I’ve finally ended at a 3.75 ⭐️. I understand how people get SJM vibes from this book in particular and agree to a certain extent. But the execution was definitely lacking. I will say what Broadbent really gets right are the villains. They are complex and nuanced and she really makes you hate them and understand them in the same go. The end also felt powerful and Max and Tisaanah will be some of my favorite characters forever. But the pacing was so rough here. It was 700 pages at basically breakneck speed from the first page and honestly should have been trimmed down as well. There are also some serious questions she left just completely unaddressed. Why is Tisaanah half Valtain? What are the parameters of magic in the world? What exactly are the Orders? The Fey/human existence? And many more. Aefe’s storyline also continued to irk me, especially when for 70 of her POV, the plot didn’t advance at all, and actually almost copied another character’s arc at the exact same time. The story as a whole has merit and I can understand why people fell in love with it, but the execution really left me wanting at times.

The perfect ending to an enchanting trilogy. I laughed, I cried, I feared & I loved. Such well written & multi-dimensional characters. A top 5 fantasy series❤️



"how much does a memory weigh" well way too much because I can't read this anymore. The writing style isn't beautiful, it's mainly just raw information, no depth or specific beauty... and a LOT of repetitive key sentences like "if you do it I do it too", "I can if you can 🤪🤪🤪"how much does a memory weigh" "are you ready? No." like I can't count how many times these are written, they become an annoying gimmick that made me cringe so hard everytime. The character arcs are so dissapointing, I wanted to slap the characters for making such stupid decisions... Not that I mind foolishness but this was just too much, no way they're choosing their paths like this, changing their minds like this. Characters get somehow brought back with either very little explanation or non at all????? 3 characters come back from the dead like this? This is just not possible for a good story. I don't know, this was just a mess and the more I read the more this story lost purpose, an endless series of battles and wars with events that just don't make any sense bcs they remain unexplained, this book seemed truly unnecessary and left a very sour taste in my mouth because after this great start w/ book one I ended up disliking the main characters, the way I view them is tainted by this chaotic story.







Highlights






I would murder someone for tea.
Vicious

"His heart is what truly lit the fires of war, and the fire burns because of you. The decision was for all of us, yes. But the vengeance? The vengeance is for you."

Death was like a lost lover. We circled each other. I craved more with every brush of its touch. All I wanted was for it to take me to its bed and never let me leave.