
Girlfriends
Reviews

Had super high expectations for this and was a little bit let down. It starts on a rocky note; not much to say for itself, too much about chain-smoking and parties the protagonists are too good for. The second half is definitely where you get the highlights, feeling way more realized than the first. Ultimately I think I was a bit more excited for this than was advisable and ended up being let down. Some of it gets so samey I feel like whole stories could be cut. Ponytail is probably the highlight. It represents a kind of girl I have seen analyzed so little and so the totality with which she is dissected here ended up being truly upsetting. It's the most interesting moment in the whole collection.
Corinne Manning's praise on the back cover actually reflects a lot of my ideas about Zhou's work here. "A writer that doesn't let you take sides ... Zhou is a true witness." This stands all too true as the author seems to have few ideas of her own other than to reflect her community.
Maybe this wickedly honest representation is refreshing for some. For me, I found it lacked internal motivation.

being a collection of short stories it feels challenging to rate the book as a whole. some works were definitely better than others. throughout the collection zhou's writing develops, the stronger stories at the end. I felt that the characters had depth, but the stories themselves could be more poignant.



Highlights

Hope was over now. I needed something firmer than that. I wasn't sure where I was supposed to look for it. In myself, to start with.