Learned by Heart
Extraordinary
Emotional
Tragic

Learned by Heart

Emma Donoghue2023
A heartbreakingly gorgeous novel based on the true story of two girls who fall secretly, deeply, and dangerously in love at boarding school in 19th century York, from the bestselling author of Room and The Wonder. Drawing on years of investigation and Anne Lister's five-million-word secret journal, Learned by Heart is the long-buried love story of Eliza Raine, an orphan heiress banished from India to England at age six, and Anne Lister, a brilliant, troublesome tomboy, who meet at the Manor School for young ladies in York in 1805 when they are both fourteen. Emotionally intense, psychologically compelling, and deeply researched, Learned by Heart is an extraordinary work of fiction by one of the world's greatest storytellers. Full of passion and heartbreak, the tangled lives of Anne Lister and Eliza Raine form a love story for the ages.
Sign up to use

Reviews

Photo of Claire E
Claire E@lamantine
3 stars
Apr 15, 2025
+2
Photo of Lindsay
Lindsay@schnurln
5 stars
Nov 11, 2023
+8
Photo of Soxie
Soxie@soxie
4 stars
Feb 9, 2024

Highlights

Photo of Lindsay
Lindsay@schnurln

Your visit has done one thing, Lister - has proved that you haven't forgotten. Only please, don't remember me like this; call me to mind as I once was. Let me shine on, like a magic-lantern slide in your head. Rich and rare were the gems she wore. All I ask is for the memory of me to haunt you as you haunt me. Let our spirits touch and go on touching always, the way one page presses itself against the next.

This highlight contains a spoiler
Photo of Lindsay
Lindsay@schnurln

And I ask myself why the present tense is the only one that matters. Can't the past be a sort of present too, if I plunge into memory and swim like a fish? Since every moment is fleeting, gone as soon as noted, so perhaps past, present, and future are all thin slices of reality, all flickering, all equally in (some sense) true.

Photo of Lindsay
Lindsay@schnurln

I press my lips together hard. So the only way to show that my confinement is unnecessary is not to object to it? If I protest against my confinemeny, I only prove that I need to be confined?

But if it's true what Dr. Mather says about the mad being capable of a sustained performance of sanity, then I wonder how many people going about their business out there in the world may only be keeping their wildest impulses in check by means of such an immense and harmful effort of will. Like actors pretending with all their might, trapped in a play on which the curtain never comes down. And if one of them does manage to keep on the mask of a sane woman for her whole life, can she not be said to be sane enough, more or less, for all intents and purposes?

This highlight contains a spoiler
Photo of Lindsay
Lindsay@schnurln

I thought we were sealed and one for ever. Was I gullible? Did you mean it then, even if you don't now? What I give, I don't, I can't take back. was yours a coward love? Did you tell me lies - or is love a story a lover tells in all sincerity, before time gives it the lie?

This highlight contains a spoiler
Photo of Lindsay
Lindsay@schnurln

Are we girls sent to school just to keep us out of the way until our services are required, Raine? Don't our lives belong to us at all?

Photo of Lindsay
Lindsay@schnurln

Have time and thinking tamed the eleven-year-old's grief, or has she only learned that there's no point in expressing it to an indifferent world?

Photo of Lindsay
Lindsay@schnurln

But it's easier to ignore the fact that there's a ladder if you're perched at the top.