Some great ideas here (and even execution, and art!), but highly uneven.

Re-reading after so many years.. (more than 10 I think) and well, even though I still remember the awesome moments in it, it's still 10-plus more fun to read than any current X-Men storyline for the past couple of years (minus the House of X/Powers of X because I haven't read that yet, which is the reason I'm reading New X-Men again now, since a friend recommended to me to reread this one before HoX-PoX, dunno why, but we'll see) Anyway, it's so much fun to read this, from the characters the plot the dialogues everything, right down to the artwork which I find awesome! Even though I get why some complain about, chars having different looks and whatnot, but Frank Quitely is an amazing artist and he pretty much made them his X-Men! Highly Recommended for X-Men fans!

Must read for X-Men fans!

Superb! Highly recommended X-Men run!

Aaaand Grant made it great.. again! Wish I had more to read after this one. Love the story & artwork.

I liked it. I would definitely recommend Morrison's X-Men to fans of the title, but it's definitely not as good and interesting as the first arc. Great artwork as always!

Continues to be solid. Plot and art. And even though I like Bachalo's art, I still miss Quitely's.

Oh, the Gainax-y ending.

3/5 Tragic, had some good character moments, and great art. Otherwise... yeah. I think even less of it now than the first time I've read it.