Name: A Night to Die For
Rating: 2.1 (5 reviews)
ISBN: 9780593481547

Lisa Schroeder

When a boy finds a girl's body in the ditch on prom night...he becomes the primary suspect in her murder. Prom dreams. Prom Screams. Mario Woods is looking forward to one normal night before he graduates. He's spent most of high school riding solo. But when fate lands him a date for prom, he figures this might be his chance to be less of a loner. Only, prom turns out to be a disaster. Just when Mario thought the night couldn’t get any worse, he sees something on the side of the road while driving home. That something is Prom Queen Maribelle Starr—murdered and left for dead. All Mario wanted was to go to prom...but somehow, he ended up in hell.

A Night to Die For

Alex 

“Look I just want to get out of here. Start over. Start a new life. I’m tired of being me.” 

The Night Of meets Carrie when a boy finds a girl's body in the ditch on prom night...and becomes the primary suspect in her murder. All Mario wants is one normal night before he graduates. He's spent most of high school riding solo and gaming with his only friend, Lucas. But when his mom asks him to take Elana Dexter to the prom as a favor to her father, his mother's boss, he figures this might be his chance to be less of a loner. Only, the night takes a turn quickly. First, Mario gets crowned Prom King alongside the school's it-girl, Maribelle Starr. Which is weird enough. But what's weirder is that when they put the crown on his head, hundreds of worms slither out of it and all over Mario. Just when Mario thought the night couldn't get any worse, he sees something on the side of the road while driving Elana home. That something is Prom Queen Maribelle Starr--murdered and left for dead. All Mario wanted was to go to prom...but somehow, he ended up in hell. Underlined is a line of totally addictive romance, thriller, and horror paperback original titles coming to you fast and furious each month. Enjoy everything you want to read the way you want to read it.

A Night to Die for

I have read Episode stories with a better plot than this. 

I genuinely cannot think of one redeeming quality about this book, so I will proceed with criticizing it. Spoilers for spoiler-y bits, you know the drill.

-There were 12 POVs. I'm not exaggerating. I counted. There were maybe 4 POVs that were worth having--Some only had one or two chapters. I wasn't invested in them, and so many of them were similar in voice. 

-I think it's fairly common to have a slightly bumbling police force in YA thrillers--if a teenager is out here solving a crime that professionals can't, but the incompetency of this one was so frustrating.

-A good mystery has well placed hints throughout the novel, not just at the 75% mark. It's not bamboozling your audience if you give no indications until you have to have a reveal. Maybe if there were less POVs it'd be more believable.

-If you're going to have a character who committed the crime have a POV, they need to clearly be hiding something.

-Everyone was annoying. The adults were awful. The teenagers sounded like stereotypes of what adults think teenagers sound like, and the adults sounded like what young teenagers think adults sound like

I did look forward to this. My hopes were immediately dashed when I saw that 

was advertised on the back. I have a review for that book up on here as well, but suffice it to say this one was just as bad as, if not worse in terms of writing/story, than 

Holly

I have read Episode stories with a better plot than this. 

I genuinely cannot think of one redeeming quality about this book, so I will proceed with criticizing it. Spoilers for spoiler-y bits, you know the drill.

-There were 12 POVs. I'm not exaggerating. I counted. There were maybe 4 POVs that were worth having--Some only had one or two chapters. I wasn't invested in them, and so many of them were similar in voice. 

-I think it's fairly common to have a slightly bumbling police force in YA thrillers--if a teenager is out here solving a crime that professionals can't, but the incompetency of this one was so frustrating.

-A good mystery has well placed hints throughout the novel, not just at the 75% mark. It's not bamboozling your audience if you give no indications until you have to have a reveal. Maybe if there were less POVs it'd be more believable.

-If you're going to have a character who committed the crime have a POV, they need to clearly be hiding something.

-Everyone was annoying. The adults were awful. The teenagers sounded like stereotypes of what adults think teenagers sound like, and the adults sounded like what young teenagers think adults sound like

I did look forward to this. My hopes were immediately dashed when I saw that Horror Hotel was advertised on the back. I have a review for that book up on here as well, but suffice it to say this one was just as bad as, if not worse in terms of writing/story, than Horror Hotel

Paige Green

Disclaimer: I received this e-arc from the publisher. Thanks! All opinions are my own.

Book: A Night To Die For

Author: Lisa Schroeder

Book Series: Standalone

Rating: 3/5

Recommended For...: young adult readers, mystery, murder mystery, prom night

Publication Date: March 1, 2022

Genre: YA Mystery

Age Relevance: 16+ (underage alcohol consumption, abelism, death, sexual content, language, drugs, religion)

Explanation of Above: There is one slight comment about abelism and talking down to a character because they have cancer. It felt a little infantizing, but the character who said it was a rude character so it fit their MO a little. There is a lot of references and mentions and showings of underage alcohol consumption. There is death mentioned, a dead body described, and some slight gore mentioning vomit and slight blood. There is some slight mentions of sexual content, mostly in jokes. There is very slight cursing; there are probably just a handful of curse words in the book. There are drugs that are just mentioned a couple of times. There is also one mention of religion.

Publisher: Underlined

Pages: 288

Synopsis: All Mario wants is one normal night before he graduates. He's spent most of high school riding solo and gaming with his only friend, Lucas. But when his mom asks him to take Elana Dexter to the prom as a favor to her father, his mother’s boss, he figures this might be his chance to be less of a loner.

Only, the night takes a turn quickly. First, Mario gets crowned Prom King alongside the school’s it-girl, Maribelle Starr. Which is weird enough. But what’s weirder is that when they put the crown on his head, hundreds of worms slither out of it and all over Mario. Just when Mario thought the night couldn’t get any worse, he sees something on the side of the road while driving Elana home. That something is Prom Queen Maribelle Starr—murdered and left for dead.

All Mario wanted was to go to prom...but somehow, he ended up in hell.

Review: This was an ok book. The book was a fast paced mystery read with mixed media format. The book had a good premise and it was interesting as it kept my interest throughout. The book also did fairly good with the mystery aspect of it.

However, the book was a bit of a let-down. There are a ton of POVS (10+) and I didn’t feel like I got a good sense of who was talking and I didn’t feel like any of these voices were distinct. The character development itself is horribly lacking and nothing clearly defines anyone. The only character who is developed is the dead girl and while this style could have been played off well, it wasn’t in this instance. There was a weird back and forth between the timelines without indication of where we were. The world building was lacking in a bunch of scenes. I had a big issue with how the investigation was handled. One of the characters questioned is a minor and should not have been questioned without being in the presence of her parent. The said minor also later went to the police twice and gave them further information, again without their parent which is illegal and something the “competent” detectives would have known. It was also foggy if the other character was a minor or not, but it was found out he was. I also was reminded of how unfair the criminal justice system was in this book, in which a family’s life savings are completely drained proving another’s innocence and they’re not paid back for the police’s mistake in arresting the wrong perpetrator, which I think needs to be overhauled when we start prison reform in this country. Anyways, aside from that I think the book would have been better if it was just a bit more developed and if the author took more time to develop the killer through hints and clues.

Verdict: It’s good, just too fast paced and needs a bit more details in it.


A Night to Die For

Reviews

Highlights