Excited when I first found out about the series and devoured this one in one day, consequently. Was rather surprised at how...technical details could become (in a good way), even when it's young adult fiction; I am not sure how many children would understand the more esoteric portions of it. Overall a plausible, if not creative, plot. Really enjoyed the 'scientific' portions of this one, but it could do better if the relationship aspects were more polished.

When this book wasn’t reminding us what a Lady Loving Straight Guy Just Being Dude™ Jim is, it was a pretty fun and breezy read. I really enjoyed the snippets of life at the Academy, the exams, rivalries and I appreciated Jim facing an opposing view on Starfleet that actually influenced and helped him in the end. Also, Uhura crumbs! The plot was quite entertaining, but like, how did no one mention Jack the Ripper at least once, even just to be reminded it’s not particularly accurate. Would probably recommend any mediocre multi-chapter academy era fic over this, which would give you more for less, but if that’s not up your alley, reading this won’t hurt. (Might adjust my rating once I get through the whole series.)