The Summer of Broken Rules
Easy read
Sweet
Simple

The Summer of Broken Rules

K. L. Walther2021
Perfect for fans of Jenny Han and Katie Cotugno, this is a story of loss, romance, and the time it takes to become who you really want to be. Meredith Fox has been going to Martha's Vineyard for the summer as long as she can remember. But this summer is the first one back since the death of Meredith's sister. It will all be overwhelming, but even more since since the entire extended family will be together for her cousin's big wedding. Unfortunately, Meredith's longtime boyfriend unexpectedly dumped her two weeks before the wedding, leaving her dateless. Luckily, she has the perfect distraction. Her family has a tradition of playing the ultimate game of Assassin every summer, and this year it will take place during the week of wedding festivities. But her target just happens to be a very cute groomsman. She's determined to not let herself get distracted, not let herself be lost in another doomed relationship. But as the week progresses, she can't help falling for him, which may cost her not only the game, but also her heart.
Sign up to use

Reviews

Photo of Chloe Yeargan
Chloe Yeargan@chloegrace
3.5 stars
Apr 16, 2025

Taylor Swift coded which I love! This was a cute & sad summer read!

This review contains a spoiler
Photo of C
C@carinaa
1.5 stars
Nov 23, 2024

It’s just very predictable.

Photo of Lina <3
Lina <3@nejmainthesky
3.5 stars
Sep 25, 2024

I don’t usually read romance but this was very sweet, a good light summer book. But him being named Stephen made me so uncomfortable because I just finished Tell me Lies, so every time she would call him Stephen, I would Imagine Stephen Demarco instead of Wit Witry, and it made me want to puke. Because Stephen Demarco makes me SICK

+10
Photo of karine ♡
karine ♡@karine
3 stars
Aug 17, 2024

3⭐️ - This book was very Taylor Swift coded and I was here for it. It was a really good fluffy rom-com. Even though at first I thought the FMC and MMC would be older and even though they fell in love in 7 days (?). I don’t understand how you do that but it’s also a book. It was entertaining and it was fluffy. What I am grateful, for is for the lack of smut or instant lust between them. I mean yeah they both fell in love in a few days but they are kids so idk it makes sense. It was a good palate cleanser after reading Billy Summers.

Photo of Madison Rajewski
Madison Rajewski @madisonraj
4 stars
Aug 13, 2024

Cute summer read.

+3
Photo of Paige Leitner
Paige Leitner@pleitner
2.5 stars
Aug 6, 2024

This book was just okay. I think the writing could've been a little more descriptive but I enjoyed the story. Just a cute and easy summer romance novel.

+4
Photo of millena
millena@versionsofmi
4 stars
Aug 3, 2024

this book made me want to rent a beach house and buy water guns

Photo of nany
nany@bibliomoon
4 stars
Jul 23, 2024

4.5 stars ⭐️ I cry now because they are so cutee. Of course Hey Stephen is the song of this book

Photo of Jennifer Gosnell
Jennifer Gosnell@jennifereveann
4 stars
Jul 19, 2024

An excellent summer romance. Very grown-up camp vibes, which I loved. Excellent setting. Loved it!

Photo of issa
issa@issaktay
4 stars
Jul 15, 2024

how i would love to be a grandmother named honey and have a large beach house that all my relatives visit each summer

Photo of EJ
EJ@elijahs
4 stars
Jun 28, 2024

I loved every single taylor swift references made in this book. Maybe because I’m like Sarah. Or maybe I just loved Wit.

Photo of Giulia Milani
Giulia Milani@giuliamilani
5 stars
Jun 25, 2024

This book surprised me! The main character is so mature. I loved the big family vibes, it reminded me of my childhood vacations!

Photo of ava<3
ava<3@ava0827
5 stars
Jun 24, 2024

This honestly might be one of my favorite books i’ve read. This is honestly such an amazing book and a perfect summer romance read.

Photo of Lauren R
Lauren R@lauren24
4 stars
May 11, 2024

this was sooo cute

Photo of Teresa Bonifácio
Teresa Bonifácio@teresabonifacio
3 stars
Apr 2, 2024

** spoiler alert ** I thought it was light read, appropriate for the Summer! However, I think 13-year-old Teresa would have been much happier reading this book! 😂 Very predictable and I think the romance part could have been explored in another way. It was fast, yet a part of me understands why Mer fell like that for Wit! Loved the family dynamic of the entire Fox family! I really enjoyed it! I think that's what made me want to keep reading until the end. Although predictable, I always thought she was going to end up with Wit in New Zealand!

Photo of Isabella
Isabella @iscbella
3 stars
Mar 13, 2024

This book is so cute!! The plot, and the characters were amazing. It's definitely a perfect summer romance read, however, my expectations were so high, and I was kind of disappointed with the insta-love. But considering it's a YA romance, the insta-love was expected (insta-love are just not my cup of tea). I love the Taylor Swift references tho. Definitely a recommend if you want a cute, and fast romance book!

Photo of Lily
Lily@616lily
5 stars
Jan 9, 2024

usually i’m not a fan of instalove but this shit was so cute, and the taylor references really sold it. killer and stephen forever <3

Photo of chel
chel@chellyace
4 stars
Jan 9, 2024

** spoiler alert ** i’d like to start by saying that i didn’t have any expectations abt this at all. just randomly saw it on booktok & as a sucker for romance books w taylor swift references, ofc i had to read it. i just let the story unfold before my eyes & it’s a good decision bc i can tell u that i had a wonderful time reading this. the book is so comforting. so carefree. so heartfelt. the setting is probably my favorite aspect of this book. if only i have the power to get transported to the farm, i will do so undoubtedly. there’s something so magical abt the place, and what makes it even more alive & wonderful is the people. their family is just so so cool & it feels like i have become one of them too. their tight-knit bond is smth i wish i have. it must be so nice to be a part of smth like this :’) also, the portrayal of grief is so :( it’s so gentle & beautiful. i feel like i have known claire personally too bc of how mer talks abt her. and i also felt how much claire loved her sister 🥹 what keeps me from rating this a full 5 is bc of how frustrating it got at some point. maybe it’s just me, but there were some parts where i found it difficult to understand the actions & intentions of the characters. also, i was not really a fan of how fast things happened between mer & wit (this proved to me that im really a slowburn gurlie) but, again, i think it’s just a matter of preferences. i still really loved their relationship & how special their connection is (really heartwaming plot twist w claire setting them up way way before they met)! claire is absolutely right when said that they’d be perfect for each other & that the fates have finally aligned. im telling u i have a compilation of every moment mer called wit his first name (my heart jumped out of joy everytime mygOd) 🥹 it also made me happy reading the epilogue & seeing how they survived long distance while growing individually too. it was a bonus that they were back at the farm, creating more memories w each other & with their big family. overall, it was a really adorable & heartwarming read. i feel like it’s going to be even more fun & lovelier the second time around. i’ll make sure to visit the farm again soon! thank you, meredith fox & stephen oscar witry 🫶

Photo of Sarah Campbell
Sarah Campbell@wiltedsarah
5 stars
Oct 30, 2023

I loved this book. I found that I really understood the character, as someone who has lost a sibling and had to continue life with a missing part of myself. Those around you continue on, when you are left behind, not knowing how to go on, wondering how everyone can just move on without them.
Finding normalcy after losing a sibling is very difficult and can sometimes take years, but I'm happy to finally have found some for myself and that the character found theirs so quickly. 
 This book was very good. It's what I like to call my weekend books: I read all the good and addicting books during the weekend so that I won't be tortured when I have to go to work and take a break from it.
Overall, five stars! 

+3
Photo of Nova <3
Nova <3@dekkernova1
5 stars
Oct 26, 2023

WOW!

+5
Photo of Maggie Hotmer
Maggie Hotmer@maggielynn8
4 stars
Oct 9, 2023

Beautiful story and very cute characters. I loved how Meredith and Wit just clicked so well from the beginning. The game of Assassin really helped add a whole other layer to the storyline. I also loved how little background memories with Claire were incorporated all throughout the book, it really helped understand where Meredith was coming from. Overall, a great book and very adorable characters. I loved all their personalities!

+6
Photo of Cara 🤍
Cara 🤍@cararicho31
5 stars
Sep 19, 2023

Listening to Taylor’s Fearless whilst reading this one = the perfect combination 🤌🏼

+4
Photo of Julia mendes
Julia mendes@juless
4 stars
Aug 28, 2023

Good summer read. Got me out of a reading slump <3

+1
Photo of den
den@biblee
2 stars
Aug 25, 2023

- meredith is SO annoying (i'm def team lulli when they fought) - claire, meredith's sister, and wit have met each other previously and i thought it would've made more sense for wit to have been in love with claire and not end up with meredith but maybe that's just me? - i honestly almost dnf-ed this but all the taylor swift references got me through it. - I GOT SECOND HAND EMBARRASSMENT FOR MEREDITH WHEN I READ THIS: "tell me about when you were younger," i randomly said. wit raised an eyebrow. "when i was younger?" "yeah, like when you were in high school." "so barely two years ago?"

Highlights

Photo of Nova <3
Nova <3@dekkernova1

''You're wicked''

''And you go wild for it''

Photo of Luna
Luna@lunascr

"You're wicked."

"You go wild for it."

Page 287
Photo of María | @AltroReader
María | @AltroReader@altroreader

It's one of those special places where you feel like time doesn't exist. Where it will always be summer, where I'll always wake up with you

This highlight contains a spoiler
Photo of María | @AltroReader
María | @AltroReader@altroreader

"You're wicked" I said.

"And you go wild for it" he said back as I jumped to the ground