Such a great mystery!! Missing people, abandoned mansion, creepy clues, cold case!! It has it all with a bit of a twist at the end!!

Impossible to put down!

Interesting plot and character dynamics. Enjoyed the mystery and trying to guess what happened. Not the most unique ending, but I enjoyed it.

good slow burn but the ending is very mediocre. the tense built up to it was far better than the conclusion.

this was definitely an entertaining mystery! i had a few theories but i would’ve never guessed the ending. i liked this but took me a while to read it because of the pace 😅

Holy f*ck.

I was beholden to this book, thinking about it all of the time. Wonderfully written across multiple timelines from multiple perspectives.

Overall I enjoyed the story and it definetly kept me hooked, but it wasn‘t my favourite thriller I‘ve ever read

I loved all the twists and turns and that I couldn’t predict the ending. Kept me interested the whole way through. The narrator was also good at differentiating characters which was nice!

This book starts slow but picks up and has you asking questions. However compared to her other books this one was a bit more predictable. Still a great read

I know they were intended that way but my god were some of the characters insufferable

** spoiler alert ** I get all excited when one of the celebrity book clubs picks a book by an author I enjoy reading, so when Good Morning America picked this book as one of it’s buzzreads, I was super happy. I even wrote “YAY” next to it in my book planner (yep, I have an entire planner just to keep track of my books). I also happened to get this one off a library hold right before a weekend, so I had all the time in the world to dig in and absorb this one. I’m not sure if I was disappointed in how long it took me to read this (about two hours), or that it had to end. That’s the best way for me to determine how much I love a book, the way it completely absorbed me and refused to allow me the opportunity to get anything done until I’m finished. This book earned an enthusiastic five stars from me! When the writer entered the picture and started piecing together the clues, I was almost positive that the girlfriend was dead and the boyfriend was off living the good life with the rich unpleasant young woman. That guy was an absolute jerkface almost from the very beginning, so it was easy for me to assume he was the bad guy and that poor girl was worm food. I was completely mistaken, but it wasn’t the other way around either. The end completely shocked me, which is one of the reasons I absolutely love Lisa Jewell’s books. She’ll keep you on the edge of your seat and still manage to shock you at the end. She is a master thriller-writer.

4.5⭐️

Lisa Jewell wrote an impressive tale this time. The first half is a bit of a slow burn but it really helps build a foundation and help you get attached to the characters, after that it's a slippery slope of I can't put this book down. I loved all the twists and how she tied up the story lines.

My colleague recommended it to me; this was the first book I read after my reading-slump and I finished it in two days. It was a real page-turner and although maybe a bit predictable at times I enjoyed reading it.

I saw the the act and the who done it. But the why was a mystery to me. OK ok. I see you Lisa

I absolutely loved this book! Definitely my favorite Lisa Jewell book to date. It doesn’t say it anywhere in the preview, but there is a sapphic romance to the novel, which of course just made me love it more!! The plot was very well developed and even though I tried to guess at the ending a few times, none of my guesses were correct. She truly knows how to take a mystery and turn it into something absolutely breathtaking.

This would be a 5 star read if the beginning wasn't so long and boring. It felt like it took forever to get to the actual story. I even put the book down for awhile. Otherwise this book was beautifully written & the story is like none other.

Sinking-Circling-Haunting. This was an interesting read and a pretty gripping mystery. The author did a good job of making you care that these young parents disappeared without a trace. The back and forth was a good way of keeping the pace moving along but I kind of felt like a lot of the book was spent on characters that I just didn't connect with or really care that much about. I wasn't able to guess the ending until pretty far in which is by design as the reader is given almost no information until very near the end. I feel like I finished this mostly because I was just very curious about what the heck happened and not because I cared what happened to the characters.

** spoiler alert ** Holy Shit! This was insane. I am a huge Lisa Jewell fan, and always have been ever since I read And Then She Was Gone. The Night She Disappeared reminded me of that book in many ways, except I feel the characters in this book got their chance at a bittersweet/yet happy ending of sorts. The first couple of chapters paint a picture that the "she" in question is Tallulah because of all the media/police attention that her mother brings to the picture, but as I crept towards the end of the book, I feel as though the book was titled from the perspective of Liam's view in regards to his "beloved" Scarlett. She left him and his purpose fell to the depths of the swimming pool on the cover... I'd be interested in seeing if anyone else feels the same way about this theory??? Overall, I hold so much respect and love for Lisa Jewell's works, and will definitely be adding this one to my recommendation list. 5/5

A story filled with mystery, disappearing people, and unanswered questions. This was great and I would have never guessed the ending of this mystery thriller. There was a multiple timeline and multiple viewpoints which really made the storyline interesting. This is the second book I've read by Lisa Jewell and I'm definitely a fan. I definitely plan to read more of her books.

Lisa Jewell has real talent for making me care about all of her characters, good and bad, warts and all. Every year she delivers another mystery, and I’m always surprised by the way she can build a world around a straightforward concept. One night, a pair of young parents Zach and Tallulah, disappear following a long night of partying on a country estate. The majority of the guests there that night, specifically the owner of the home Scarlett, disappear in their own ways, and Tallulah’s mother Kim is left seeking answers. A year later, Sophie, a crime writer, moves to the village and becomes entangled in the mystery. This book had shades of the author’s other novel, When She Disappeared, but only really in the premise. Tallulah’s story in the past blends perfectly with Sophie’s investigation in the present. I had a hard time getting into the initial start, but then I could not put this book down. Every Lisa Jewell Book becomes My Favorite Lisa Jewell Book, and The Night She Disappeared is no different. It’s the perfect way to cap off the summer, a creepy, clever little mystery to kick off fall. Thanks to Net Galley and Atria Books for the ARC!

I heard about this book on the Books and the City podcast and had been looking for a mystery/thriller and figured why not? I’d never read a book by Jewell before and I’m not sure if her style meshes well with me. You truly had to WANT to read this book. Between the multiple timelines that constantly pulled you out of the story and the slower than molasses pacing, it was a challenge to keep reading it. The mystery of what had happened to these young parents is what truly kept me reading, but the story was way too long. I understand why we needed this fully painted out backstory for our characters and for the two years leading up to the discovery of what truly happened that night. I slightly wish I had DNF’d it and just looked up the ending. If you have the time to commit to it, it was interesting but if not just spoil yourself because the ending wasn’t worth it to me.

Slow burn mystery with multiple POVs and timelines and suspense that never goes away - probably Lisa Jewell's best work to date.