A Girl is a Half-formed Thing
Vivid
Expressive
Tragic

A Girl is a Half-formed Thing

Eimear McBride's novel tells the story of a young woman's relationship with her brother after a tumour leaves him severely brain damaged. Not so much a stream of consciousness, as an unconscious railing against a life that makes little sense, and a shocking and intimate insight into the thoughts, feelings and sensual urges of a vulnerable and isolated protagonist, to read A Girl is a Half-Formed Thing is to plunge inside its narrator's head, experiencing her world first-hand. This isn't always comfortable - but it is always a revelation.
Sign up to use

Reviews

Photo of Lindy
Lindy@lindy

This Book is Full of Half-formed Sentences

Photo of Essence
Essence@iridessence
4 stars
Dec 21, 2023

it took me a bit to get into it because I’ve never read a book with this kind of writing style but once i got into the grove of it I actually really liked it

Photo of Mia Caven
Mia Caven@miacaven
4 stars
Oct 10, 2023

A sad and touching story but I couldn’t truly get with the way it was written. It got better by the end and was very emotional but the way it was written meant I couldn’t connect with the character. Additionally I think books like this that are pure negative experiences and no positive ones are a hard read for me. Life is negative but it also is positive (for example a little life; such a sad story but it had moments of beautiful happiness too which is why I loved it because that way it was realistic)! I can see the potential and I think it’s great so much was conveyed with honestly such little genuinely said.

Photo of Tailah Clarkson
Tailah Clarkson@tailahclarkson
3 stars
Aug 21, 2022

genius writing. never seen it before but it was so cleverly crafted that i could grasp so vividly despite the broken english and grammar

+3
Photo of Heather Ellis
Heather Ellis@thelitarchive
4 stars
Aug 30, 2021

I read this with the full knowledge that the subject matter would be hard and heartbreaking, but I had no idea about the difficulty the prose would cause me. I consider myself a pretty fast reader, I can read through classics fairly easily and if it is a well-written book I can finish it in about 2-3 days while still appreciating and analysing the author's motivations. However, this book, this tiny book, took me over a week to read. I agonised over the prose and the lack of sentences in some sections. I loved that McBride did this, I was forced to appreciate every word, sentence and phrase that she had decided to write down. The messy prose mirrored the messy life that 'the girl' had throughout the narrative. I saw that someone wrote it was like a long string of poetry, which I would agree with, but I also think its much more than that. I want to pick McBride's brain and ask her how she was able to write this way, and still create meaning for her readers and her characters.

Photo of Charlie Demosthenous
Charlie Demosthenous@sharkie3
4 stars
Feb 4, 2024
Photo of clara
clara@sophierosenfeld
1.5 stars
Jan 26, 2024
Photo of Minjae
Minjae@mjseason
5 stars
Jun 28, 2023
+2
Photo of Lina.
Lina.@murmuration
1 star
Jun 8, 2024
Photo of Ricky Burgess
Ricky Burgess@rrricky
3 stars
Apr 2, 2024
Photo of azliana aziz
azliana aziz@heartinidleness
3 stars
Jan 13, 2024
Photo of Will Vunderink
Will Vunderink@willvunderink
3 stars
Dec 18, 2023
Photo of Jason Skicewicz
Jason Skicewicz@jskitz
3 stars
Oct 25, 2022
Photo of Zaynab Waqas
Zaynab Waqas@unicorn_blood
1 star
Oct 1, 2022
Photo of Iris Emily
Iris Emily@desirepath
4 stars
Aug 28, 2022
Photo of Edward
Edward@edwahd
5 stars
Aug 12, 2022
Photo of Tugce Arslan Ucer
Tugce Arslan Ucer@tugcearslan
4 stars
Mar 9, 2022
Photo of Roger Amundsen
Roger Amundsen@gododger
4 stars
Mar 8, 2022
Photo of James Haliburton
James Haliburton@jdhberlin
4 stars
Jan 11, 2022
Photo of Tamara Hazlehurst
Tamara Hazlehurst @tamarah
5 stars
Jan 2, 2022
Photo of Jennifer
Jennifer@vivaldi
1 star
Dec 14, 2021
Photo of Moray Lyle McIntosh
Moray Lyle McIntosh@bookish_arcadia
3 stars
Dec 5, 2021
Photo of Jade Flynn
Jade Flynn@jadeflynn
5 stars
Nov 20, 2021
Photo of Catherine Nicolai
Catherine Nicolai@cnic
3 stars
Nov 5, 2021