
Reviews

born in 1918 muriel spark gets it… this book felt like a trapse through girlhood and gentley reminds us that our perceptions change over time, super fun read

Absolutely amazing.

3.5 stars.

I'm not completely sure if I've liked this book or not. The story is fascinating, but I would have liked a bit more character development.

Immediately after finishing the book, I gave it three stars. A few hours on, I'm revising it to five. The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie is one of those books that offer a strong formal/linguistic resistance to the reader, in this case, the jerky, dialogue-ridden narration, but amply reward those that persevere. The novel fares bitter on the palate despite the smattering of beautiful passages here and there. It is the exquisite execution of its unsavoury flavourings that makes the book the classic that it is. The well-worn setting (of a school) and premise (of the teacher-student dynamic)-have been rendered striking through a clever blend of the familiar and shocking, while remaining very, very real all the time. Miss Brodie and her créme de la créme, needless to say, are going to stay with me for a while now.

This is the type of novel that would come alive in film (which surely means I should watch the movie). The betrayal! The manipulation! The subterfuge! Jean Brodie is all at once enigmatic and wicked. She's such a sour turn off the classic mentor/teacher trope that I nearly recoiled, because she reminded me so much of an old teacher of mine. What a sharp look at the dark side of the teacher/student dynamic.


















Highlights

Therefore the sewing lessons were a great relaxation to all, and Miss Brodie in the time before Christmas used the sewing period cach week to read Jane Eyre to her class who, while they listened, pricked their thumbs as much as was bearable so that interesting little spots of blood might appear on the stuff they were sewing, and it was even possible to make blood-spot designs.
girlhood