Scandalous

Nah. This book deserves to be erased from everyone’s mind. They’re great parents in Luna’s book. But their book is shit ty.

3.5. I lowered half a star during this re-read. I enjoyed it a lot, but realized I didn't care as much.

I liked the parts with Luna. She might be my favorite kid in this series.

5/5★ ↓ Pues me ha gustado mucho la historia de Edie y Trent. Esta novela es el tercer libro de la serie 'Sinners of Saint'. Los protagonistas me han gustado mucho. Mucho más Edie que Trent. Edie me ha parecido un personaje increíble. Tiene una historia dura, muy dura y difícil que a día de hoy le sigue afectando. Se me ha roto el corazón leyendo todo lo que ha sufrido y sigue sufriendo. Me ha gustado mucho su personalidad. Es una chica fuerte, amable, divertida y que lucha con todas sus fuerzas por la gente que quiere. Eso me ha encantado. Su personaje me ha conquistado. Por otra parte, quizá Trent me ha gustado menos, pero no quiere decir que no me haya gustado. Creo que también ha sido un personaje interesante. También ha tenido un pasado difícil y a día de hoy lidia con algunos problemas. Edie y Trent no tienen nada en común. Son dos personas súper diferentes, pero se complementan muy bien. Tienen una relación diferente, complicada pero que a ellos les hace felices. Les da igual lo que opine la gente. Ellos saben lo que tienen, lo que verdaderamente importante y ha sido genial. Me ha encantado que aparecieran los protagonistas de los anteriores libros. También disfruté mucho con esos libros y reencontrarse con ellos ha sido estupendo. 'Scandalous' es una historia increíblemente adicto, que engancha desde el primer momento y no puedes parar de leer. Es una historia divertida, entretenida y muy sexy. Una historia que va más allá de una historia de amor. Es una historia de superación y valentía y ha sido muy muy guay. He disfrutado mucho con esta lectura.

2 stars mainly for the take down of Jordan (still meh but I will take what I can get)

Let me start by saying this book was not great. There were some comments made by Trent that made me uncomfortable. “She looked so much like a kid I wanted to punch myself in the balls for imagining her,” and again at “Edie’s legs were still curve-less, two straight toothpicks. Not very different from Luna’s.” Now, who would imagine or compare a woman you’re interested in to your daughter like that. This book didn’t do the age gap trope justice unlike, ‘Birthday Girl,’ which I enjoyed and rated 5 stars. This on the other hand, is getting two stars with uncomfortable comments and that the romance was extremely boring in my opinion. Yes, there were some genuine moments and there was somewhat of a good connection but I didn’t feel the chemistry. Usually I don’t do long reviews unless I have lots of thoughts or if I hate / love it but this one needed some type of a review with how bad it was.

She's done it again *slow clap*. I think we can all agree that the love angst and overcoming a villainous foe usually make up a decent L.J Shen book. It was good. Not amazing but a good read. Also can everyone try to remember that books are just that, books. They do not always, especially in fiction, portray the authors ideologies or morals. If the subject matter is triggering to you seek out those trigger warning before reading rather than trashing the book for not meeting your moral compass.

”...And it was funny, how people viewed Edie as the kid because of her age, when she’d been nothing but a lioness throughout her short life.” So yeah, a big hug to Edie and Luna. A big punch and a ‘fuck you’ to Trent. I don’t know what is it with LJ Shen going on extreme lengths and dropping unsettling scenes in every book I’ve read by her(It wasn’t even about the huge age gap. Edie was a grown up in many ways and that mostly prevented me from dwelling on the fact that she was actually 15 years younger). I brushed it off in ‘Vicious’ because Vicious was a psychotic egomaniac and that kind of behavior wasn’t out of his character. I brushed it off in ‘Ruckus’ because Dean warned Rosie to back off unless she was 100% certain and she still gave him the green light. But I can’t, for the love of me, brush off the scene in this book with Edie finding Trent and Sonya in Trent’s office! Was that supposed to be hot?! Was that supposed to be arousing?! I don’t know about you but it was outright disgusting and creepy. Not to mention manipulative. Based solely on Trent’s selfish and absurd deal that made no sense at all!!!! I loved Edie! She may be the best SOS female protagonist. Nothing about her said ‘teenager’ because she was—unsolicitedly of course—way too mature for her age and knew exactly what she wanted to do with her life. I loved her devotion to Theo, her relationship with Luna and her friendship with Bane which really was goalz. Trent, on the other hand, was just a pissed of, bitter and possessive asshole who didn’t really put any proper effort in bonding with her daughter and was sort of competing with Edie for no reason at all. What really surprised me was that I thought he was worse than Vicious. The best thing in this book was the relationships but not the one between Trent and Edie. I’m getting tired of the unchanging dynamic that keeps coming back again and again in this series. And I feel like—depending on what I’ve heard—it’ll happen again in ‘Angry God.’ I will read All Saints High, though. Only because I wanna know Luna and Knight’s story. I’ll decide about Vaughn after I’ll have finished the book. But I don’t really give a damn about Daria.

3.5 stars. i have mixed feelings because this was my favorite l.j. shen book i've read so far and i'd been highly anticipating this one ever since trent's introduction in defy, but still i had a lot of problems with it. i don't know how to explain it but i just couldn't feel the love the characters supposedly had for each other. i felt like the relationship was mostly physical and sexual than emotional. that doesn't mean that their relationship did not develop, because it did, they ended up leaning on each other more and depend on each other more especially with their family issues, but i never felt like that emotional connection was conveyed very well in the book. only in the end did they even acknowledge that they 'love each other' and i just couldn't believe it because throughout the book all they did was get physical with each other and never once did they discuss their feelings whatsoever. personally, i did not buy into the whole 'she's in my blood, he's my ocean' thing, i just couldn't help but cringe and just go like 'sure, jan' on them. i also thought we were gonna get more of trent dealing with his own daughter and the focus would be on those two characters but instead i feel like edie interacted more with luna than trent himself -her own father- which was kinda disappointing since i was really looking forward to seeing more of that father/daughter relationship, and even more of a development when it came to that topic. i really liked edie and i think she's my favorite heroine out of all of shen's books i've read since she was the one that actually had somewhat of a personality and wasn't just a carbon copy of emilia leblanc, so that's a positive i guess. and when it comes to trent....oof do i have some mixed feelings. he was always the most intriguing to me out of the four hotholes, but i couldn't connect at all with his character when all he did was put up this impersonal and cold persona. when he was with edie i just couldn't feel anything at all because all their scenes, regardless of how close and physical they were, they felt cold and detached, because trent acted that way. he didn't even kiss her throughout the damn book!!! how am i supposed to root for them when i can't help but feel sorry for edie for the way she was treated, like some detached, random hookup. i don't know, again this is how i personally felt about trent's behavior towards edie. maybe it's just me that felt uncomfortable for edie but i just couldn't get on board with that.

Guys, when I tell you L.J Shen has worked her magic once again!!

5 Stars!!!! I fell in love with this book ... definitely my favourte out of the series so far

Better than the first book!

Loved that twist at the end. This series is so addictive. 😍

Perfection

3.5. I lowered half a star during this re-read. I enjoyed it a lot, but realized I didn't care as much.