
The Girl Who Takes an Eye for an Eye A Lisbeth Salander novel, continuing Stieg Larsson's Millennium Series
Reviews

This book made the same mistakes as the last book in the series. The writing style was easy to get into but the characters fell flat. I felt like the realistic writing style of the original trilogy was especially missing in this book. The writing style felt like it was trying to replicate the writing style of the original trilogy but failed and became rambling descriptions. There were many new characters who didn’t have strong enough personalities for me to visualize them. The plot is very convoluted compared to the previous books. I didn’t like the book except for the ending.

Definitely feels like there's something missing, which is a shame as I love this series. While the last book still had echoes of Larsson, it really feels devoid of his voice this time around.

Not bad. I think the sentence structure and general flow suffered in the translation, unless the writing style was stilted to begin with. Sufficiently intriguing for me to go back and read the rest of the series at some point.

I find it really good but to be honest not as good as the previous books.

Why does somebody who has no interest in the characters and the spirit of original trilogy continue to write these books? There is again no character development to speak of, all them actually feel like they never had arcs and remain static so buddy can think up contrived plot lines. Salander is again toothless and relegated to a secondary plot thread for the most part, with Micke, who is actually never called that again I think?, is investigating everything and tying it all together. Who cares that she’s better than him about it because when she knows she just doesn’t feel like telling anybody anything except for little hints. Again, all the character progression from the original movies just being erased. It’s tropey as hell again too. More twins. Of course there’s Muslim extremists demonstrating how shitty they are to women. It’s all just so contrived and not bolstered with a larger political stance yet again. The author clearly has nothing to say—whether through the characters or through the premise or plot. It’s a cash cow being milked. A standard arrangement for a thriller with a kind or mystery. Which, had it been arranged different, would have actually been far more compelling too. And on top of that, when it does flashbacks there is suddenly no formatting so it’s actually annoying to read it. Had the end actually been a prologue—especially considering it’s uhhh the f*ing past—the mystery would have been planted right away. He could have teased a part of WHY Lisbeth is in prison at the start beyond the original excuse as well as planting a little seed of what the heck happened in those woods? And then each part just continued those stories until the woods come up again. Instead it’s been arranged in as boring a way as is possible. We are neither allowed to hear the inner workings of most characters, nor do we get prose that actually explain anything. It’s completely sterile throughout. This guy hates similes. I guarantee you this is a “show, don’t tell” author, ironically who just doesn’t show very well at all. The result is very, I don’t know, “meh”, thriller. At least it was shorter than the last one, though.

The Millennium Series is my favourite crime thriller series...but I have to admit I don't like how the "new" Lisbeth is portrayed in Lagercrantz's books. She is definitely not the same girl from the first three books I have come to love.

Loved it!! But seriously, what's not to love! Seamless continuation of an amazing series. Thanks

Not as good as earlier books in the series.. but Lisbeth Salander makes it worth reading.

Can this series continue? I sincerely hope so. All a ends beautifully woven together makes such a great read.

But what else can Lisbeth get up to?














This book appears on the shelf Historical fiction
This book appears on the shelf Read 2013




