Valentine's Day Sucks

When the mother of vampire Jessica O'Halloran calls to say she's shot and trapped Cupid AKA Eros in her backyard, Jessica and her husband go out to her mom's isolated lake cabin to investigate. It turns out they can't release Eros from his backyard bonds because he's under the beguilement of a pixie and getting a little too free with the golden arrows. The immortal is being forced to give Jessica's mom what she says doesn't want: true love.