Wish You Were Here
Surprising
Repetitive
Dry

Wish You Were Here

Jodi Picoult2021
An upcoming book to be published by Penguin Random House.
Sign up to use

Reviews

Photo of Elisavet Rozaki
Elisavet Rozaki @elisav3t
3 stars
May 20, 2024

Obnoxious main character... but bonus points for the twist!

Photo of hanni
hanni@whatsureta

im pissed about gabriel not being real... and i hate finn

Photo of Elle May
Elle May@ellexmay
4 stars
Jan 17, 2024

My sister gave me this book to read, I'm sure she knew I would like it more than she did. I purposely avoided the description of this book so I could find out for myself, I'm glad I did! The book is set within the Covid pandemic which made me relive just how scared and stressed the lockdown had made me, but I got a sense of relief that Diana was safe on a beautiful island away from it all. Then the twist came... I was devastated for Diana, I won't go into too much detail, but I will say snapping back to reality can be heartbreaking. Overall, I loved the book. The ending left me frustrated, and I needed to know more.

Photo of ♡
@miam
4 stars
Jan 7, 2024

it is rlly slow-burn and boring at the early pages.. and somehow doesn't make sense as we alr escape the pandemic, but i found the hunch as diana's recovery from time to time; the counciousness therapy, her longing, and the maze island

Photo of Melissa Palmer
Melissa Palmer@melissapalmer404
4 stars
Nov 5, 2023

For me, this didn't feel like a typical Picoult book but I ended up really liking it. Set in present pandemic times, this book talks about making choices about your life, your career, your love and your family. It is extremely well written. I liked it a lot.

Photo of Patricia Nelson
Patricia Nelson@tnelson577
5 stars
Aug 23, 2023

This book was an 'extra, optional' book club book, and I'm SO GLAD I read it. I'm beginning to realize that I love everything I read from this author. The premise - a woman gets stranded on vacation in the Galapagos and away from her significant other who is a front-line doctor in NYC at the beginning of the Covid-19 Pandemic in March, 2020. The story swept me along as she got her footing in her new surroundings and became a part of that community, while having limited contact with NY and her life outside of paradise. Meanwhile, her boyfriend is drowing in Covid patients in NY and hoping she is ok. I saw an interview with the author where she mentioned that she interviewed front line workers while writing the book, and that they were so grateful to tell their story, and the truth of what it was like in the hospitals in 2020. I can't go into more detail about the turns the story takes without major spoilers, but it's a great read with so so much to discuss. Things like - what if we step off the path we are on and really look at it to see if it is still what we want, or what we would choose? Examine if we believe in things we can't understand, or that don't make sense. What would we risk to have a last chance to speak to a loved one? I can't wait for book club to discuss alllllll of it. Highly recommend. First five-star read of 2023!

Photo of Elizabeth Wood
Elizabeth Wood@ejwood41
5 stars
Aug 21, 2023

I’m on a roll with 5 ⭐️ books. This book may not be for everyone, but I truly enjoyed it. It does cover a lot about the pandemic so if that is a touchy subject, it might not be my first recommendation. However, I loved the characters. I loved the twist. I loved the ending. There were also a ton of great one-liners. All around wonderful book.

Photo of Kaitlyn Bailey
Kaitlyn Bailey @readwith-kaitlyn
1 star
Jul 26, 2023

The beginning was great I loved the thought of her being on holiday and meeting someone new, but I was just really disappointed when she woke up it feels like a story you would write in primary school.

Photo of Lorraine
Lorraine@lollyb
4 stars
Jul 12, 2023

Always been a Jodi Picoult fan so expected to enjoy this book, but it was better than I thought it would be. I’m glad I left it so long to read after the pandemic, as it would have been too soon after our world was put on pause and we saw so much suffering. I think she has beautifully recorded that time in our lives, it made me remember how scary it was and I found myself crying quite a few times throughout the book, but I also found it heartwarming. Finally, the twist in the middle, I did not see coming at all! This will be a book I recommend in the future.

Photo of Christa Bell
Christa Bell@christalouwho
2.5 stars
Jun 30, 2023

As far as factual information goes about how different groups of people endured the pandemic, Jodi Picoult did an exceptional job. Never thought I’d be reading about Covid just a few years later but that’s what made it kind of neat. It connected the reader to the story immediately.

I hated that sometimes things said in Spanish were translated in English while other phrases were left to interpretation. I found myself using google translate more often than I would have liked while trying to read this book.

After the “twist” things got real repetitive and boring for me. I had to push through to the ending only because I really wanted to see how The Greens resident portion played out. That went as expected but everything else fell flat.

+2
Photo of erin alise
erin alise @thehollowvalley
3.5 stars
Feb 17, 2023

I wanted more from this book and also somehow wanted less? The twist was interesting, but I found a lot of what came after it repetitive and extraneous. Overall a strange pace, but it kept me entertained enough.

+3
Photo of Samaa alaa eldin
Samaa alaa eldin@samaa
2 stars
Sep 1, 2022

Can't stress enough how much I hated Diana's character development.

Photo of Allison
Allison@agent98
4 stars
Aug 14, 2022

Rooted for the dream to be true

This review contains a spoiler
Photo of Sara Borden
Sara Borden@sgborden
2 stars
Aug 12, 2022

this book starts off very slow, but i will admit there was a twist i did not see coming. i found it odd to read about a period of time that we’ve all just experienced. the book left me feeling slightly annoyed, but there were certain aspects of the book i did enjoy!

Photo of Bethany Jenkins
Bethany Jenkins@bluepenguin17
3.75 stars
Jun 22, 2022

I love Jodi Picoult for the way that she writes about humanity, and this book is no exception. It is surprising, and it offers a reflective perspective on the Covid-19 pandemic.

Good book, just not up there with Picoult's very best.

+4
Photo of Lauren Attaway
Lauren Attaway@camcray
5 stars
Jan 26, 2022

This book, this book. I was very anxious to read a book that not only took place during Covid but was rumored to reference it very significantly in terms of the plot, but I am glad that I pushed past my hesitations. If you are going to read a novel about Covid, you want it to be as compassionate and carefully researched at this one. Seriously, I read the entire acknowledgements, because I was so curious on how she got so much right. Diana and her boyfriend Finn live in New York City, he is a surgical resident, and she works in Art Sales. They are both very driven and have been planning out their lives with exacting energy. It is 2020, and they have saved for a vacation to the Galapagos for like four years. When Covid first appears in the horizon that March, he tells her to go on the trip without him on their dream vacation, because they cannot the deposit back. She goes and winds up in lockdown on an island, where she gradually becomes increasingly involved with the family that takes her in. There is a twist after the halfway point that you will not see coming, but this book really did a fantastic job of giving you that look at how easy one choice changes everything. I could not put this book down, and I thought I was sick of talking about the last year. Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for the ARC.

Photo of Ineta Poliscenko
Ineta Poliscenko@inetareads
5 stars
Jan 4, 2022

Jodi has done great work describing the ugliness of it all The notes from doctor, the bruised faces under masks, the emotional breakdowns, the change in perspective and switch of life values. The despair of those isolating and being trapped from loved ones. The confusion that teenagers and kids had to go though. Watching your loved ones die. Having Covid yourself and recovering from it. Read more on Instagram @inetareads

+4
Photo of Jennifer Dieter
Jennifer Dieter@jdeets03
4 stars
Dec 30, 2021

Jodi Picoult always has what I need to pull me out of a reading slump. I couldn’t put this one down! It has the signature Picoult twist that I didn’t see coming. It does center the Covid pandemic but isn’t overly graphic. While well researched, it didn’t feel like the research shadowed the plot and characters as can sometimes happen in a Piccoult novel. I really liked Diana as a character and appreciated her journey toward self-discovery.

Photo of Kourtney
Kourtney@familywithbooks
3 stars
Dec 20, 2021

It’s publication day for Jodi Picoult’s latest novel, Wish You Were Here. As I just finished the story, I’m going to try my best to sum up my feelings, but first - some warnings. 1) When you read the synopsis, it sounds intriguing - a girl leaves New York at the start of the pandemic for a vacation without her doctor boyfriend and has to learn to become a local of the Galápagos Islands while the world closes down. This is true for 61% of the book. Then a twist happens and it’s most definitely not about that anymore. Sort of. Kind of. 2) This is a COVID story. It’s Jodi Picoult - she does not do anything half hearted. She researches the subject she is writing about and will tell you every good, bad and weird detail there is. This book brings us back to the scary days of wiping down everything and not knowing what’s to come. Of losing our jobs, our homes, and struggling with our new reality. It discusses about being intubated - if you have been touched by a COVID case or death that is hard to think about, you may want to wait on this read. With those triggers in mind, I thought I would be ok to read this. But I wasn’t. I pushed through because of receiving the ARC and wanting to post a review, but COVID is too fresh for me. Reading about wiping off food and what healthcare workers were going through is difficult enough on a good day. For my reading entertainment? I just couldn’t get into it. The twist? Genius. Discussing the twist? That felt a bit tiresome. It is an interesting thing but it felt like too much detail. I was also very surprised at how cavalier Picoult’s character Diana was for COVID safety that were never really addressed. Finn would get mad at her but then 30 seconds later it was like it never happened. Ummm. What? I don’t know if I would rate this higher if I read it say in 5 years from now. For that reason I will give it ⭐️⭐️⭐️. Excuse me while I go read a holiday story now. Thank you to the publishers for providing a copy for review via NetGalley!

Photo of Somya Verma
Somya Verma@somyaverma
4.5 stars
Sep 14, 2024
Photo of Jessica Ford
Jessica Ford@jessford
5 stars
Mar 20, 2023
Photo of Shelby Wheeler
Shelby Wheeler@shelbywheeler
4 stars
Feb 28, 2023
Photo of Anna Bostick
Anna Bostick@aebostick
4.5 stars
Jul 18, 2022
Photo of Nohemi Reale
Nohemi Reale@mimi0523
5 stars
Jul 5, 2022

Highlights

Photo of Jamie Loh
Jamie Loh@jamieloh

Ask anyone who's nearly died: you should live in the moment.

Unfortunately, that's impossible. Every moment keeps slipping past. You can only go on to the next moment and the one after that, seeking out what you love most with whom you love most. All those moments, tallied up? That's your life. Bucket lists aren't important. Benchmarks aren't important. Neither are goals. You take the wins in small ways: Did I wake up this morning? Do I have a roof over my head? Are the people I care about doing okay? You don't need the things you don't have. You only need what you've got, and the rest? It's just gravy.


I wrote my master’ thesis on the reliability of memory, and how it fails us. In Japan, there are monuments called tsunami stones- giant tablets on the coastlines warn descendants of earlier settlers not to build their homes past a certain point. They date back to 1896, when two tsunamis killed 22,000 people. The Japanese believe that it takes three generations to forget. Those who experience a trauma pass it along to their children and their grandchildren, and then the memory fades. To the survivors or a tragedy, that’s unthinkable- what’s the point of living through something terrible if you cannot convey the lessons you’ve learned? Since nothing will ever replace all you’ve lost, the only way to make meaning is to make sure no one else goes through what you did. Memories are the safeguards we use to keep from making the same mistakes.

This highlight contains a spoiler
Photo of ashwitherow
ashwitherow@bessiew

Trying to figure out what happened to me isn’t important. It’s what I do with what I’ve learned that counts.

Page 282
Photo of Ineta Poliscenko
Ineta Poliscenko@inetareads

The only way you can tell how far you've come is to know where you started