Name: Jeanne L Collier's review of Bone Crier's Dawn by Kathryn Purdie
Item: Bone Crier's Dawn
Rating: 3
Author: Jeanne L Collier

Kathryn Purdie

Ailesse and her friends change the afterlife in the gripping conclusion to the fantasy duology that began with Bone Crier's Moon from New York Times bestselling author Kathryn Purdie--perfect for fans of Stephanie Garber and Roshani Chokshi. Love is a matter of life and death. Bone Criers have been ferrying the dead into the afterlife for centuries, a dangerous duty only possible with the powers they gain from sacrificing their amourés the men destined to love them and die. But Bone Criers Ailesse and Sabine--along with Ailesse's love, Bastien--are working to chart their own course and rewrite the rules of the afterlife. If they don't break the soul between Ailesse and her amouré, she could die--just as Bastien's father did. Sabine struggles to maintain her authority as matrone of her famille--the role always destined for her sister--even as she fights to control the violent jackal power within her. Bastien is faced with a new dilemma as the spirits of the Underworld threaten the souls of his friends--and his father. Ailesse attempts to resist her mother's siren song as she's drawn into her own version of the Underworld. How will she save her friends once she's cut off from their world? This pulse-pounding follow-up to Bone Crier's Moon is a story of love, sisterhood, and determination as three friends find the courage and power to shatter the boundary between the living and the dead.

Bone Grace #2

Bone Crier's Dawn

Ailesse and her friends change the afterlife in the gripping conclusion to the fantasy duology that began with Bone Crier’s Moon from New York Times bestselling author Kathryn Purdie—perfect for fans of Stephanie Garber and Roshani Chokshi. Love is a matter of life and death. Bone Criers have been ferrying the dead into the afterlife for centuries, a dangerous duty only possible with the powers they gain from sacrificing their amourés, the men destined to love them and die. But Bone Criers Ailesse and Sabine—along with Ailesse’s love, Bastien—are working to chart their own course and rewrite the rules of the afterlife. If they don’t break the soul bond between Ailesse and her amouré, she could die—just as Bastien’s father did. Sabine struggles to maintain her authority as matrone of her famille—the role always destined for her sister—even as she fights to control the violent jackal power within her. Bastien is faced with a new dilemma as the spirits of the Underworld threaten the souls of his friends—and his father. Ailesse attempts to resist her mother’s siren song as she’s drawn into her own version of the Underworld. How will she save her friends once she’s cut off from their world? This pulse-pounding follow-up to Bone Crier’s Moon is a story of love, sisterhood, and determination as three friends find the courage and power to shatter the boundary between the living and the dead.

Alessia (Taylor's version) 

Nicole Salcedo

"Bone Criers have been ferrying the dead into the afterlife for centuries, a dangerous duty only possible with the powers they gain from sacrificing their amoures the men destined to love them and die. But Bone Criers Ailesse and Sabine-along with Ailesse's love, Bastien-are working to chart their own course and rewrite the rules of the afterlife. If they don't break the soul between Ailesse and her amoure, she could die-just as Bastien's father did. Sabine struggles to maintain her authority as matrone of her famille-the role always destined for her sister-even as she fights to control the violent jackal power within her. Bastien is faced with a new dilemma as the spirits of the Underworld threaten the souls of his friends-and his father. Ailesse attempts to resist her mother's siren song as she's drawn into her own version of the Underworld. How will she save her friends once she's cut off from their world? This pulse-pounding follow-up to Bone Crier's Moon is a story of love, sisterhood, and determination as three friends find the courage and power to shatter the boundary between the living and the dead."--

I struggled a little with the ending...  Do people deserve redemption/forgiveness/whatnot?  I believe so.  Should they have to work for it?  Yes.

Jeanne L Collier

Tatiana

Bone Crier's Dawn: 2/5

“Their peace is my peace, and it satisfies far deeper than revenge.”

Oof, this book is just a big mess. I didn't love the first one but definitely thought it had potential. The book's overall idea is really intriguing, so I had a good feeling for this sequel of Bone Crier's Moon.

Premise:
As it is the sequel of Bone Crier's Moon, I don't want to say too much, as it would be a spoiler. We are met with our three points of view again, Bastian, Ailesse, and Sabine. The three embark on a quest to change the afterlife rules while wrestling with struggles of their own.

Writing & Plot:
Once again, I was very intrigued by this sequel, and it was definitely one I needed to pick up. That being said, it just didn't deliver for me. I thought the whole thing was kind of a mess with an incoherent plot and was overall boring. I really had to push myself to finish this and contemplated DNFing a lot.

The writing is okay; there's nothing wrong with it except that it is sometimes repetitive. I think the major downfall of this book is the plot & the characters. I felt like the entire thing was also predictable, making it that much harder to get through.

Characters:
Let me preface this by saying I wasn't a fan of Ailesse and Bastian in Bone Crier's Moon, but this book just managed to make it worse. I literally felt nothing for them. Alone, their characters are one-dimensional and boring, and together it feels forced and awkward. Ailesse is so annoying about Matron and cant to be happy for Sabine even if it killed her. Don't even get me started on the love triangle between Cas, Bastian, and Ailesse. Literally the most pointless and awkward encounter of all time.

The one saving grace is Sabine. Badass as she is. I also didn't mind the romance between her and Cas. I think they're cute.

Conclusion:
This book was all over the place, and I was just not a fan. I felt like this book could make or break this series for me, and ultimately, I'm not too fond of the duology. Again, I think the premise and potential are there, but the characters and plot need work. 

Overall, I, unfortunately, wouldn't recommend this series. I think some other books and duologies do what this book does, but 100x better. I feel bad, but that's just how I feel. Disappointed, and not for me.

Isabel Menchón Martínez

This was a fun duology and while it doesn’t read beautifully necessarily (not bad, but nothing special) it really redeemed itself with the character development. I appreciated all the characters involved and I kept wanting to know what was gonna happen. POVs can be difficult if you dislike any characters but I found myself excited to reach each person’s chapter. Also cool world interesting history. I would recommend for any easy read.

Laura Wilson

Ailesse and her friends change the afterlife in the gripping conclusion to the fantasy duology that began with Bone Crier's Moon from New York Times bestselling author Kathryn Purdie--perfect for fans of Stephanie Garber and Roshani Chokshi. Now available in paperback. Love is a matter of life and death. Bone Criers have been ferrying the dead into the afterlife for centuries, a dangerous duty only possible with the powers they gain from sacrificing their amourés, the men destined to love them and die. But Bone Criers Ailesse and Sabine--along with Ailesse's love, Bastien--are working to chart their own course and rewrite the rules of the afterlife. If they don't break the soul bond between Ailesse and her amouré, she could die--just as Bastien's father did. Sabine struggles to maintain her authority as matrone of her famille--the role always destined for her sister--even as she fights to control the violent jackal power within her. Bastien is faced with a new dilemma as the spirits of the Underworld threaten the souls of his friends--and his father. Ailesse attempts to resist her mother's siren song as she's drawn into her own version of the Underworld. How will she save her friends once she's cut off from their world? This pulse-pounding follow-up to Bone Crier's Moon is a story of love, sisterhood, and determination as three friends find the courage and power to shatter the boundary between the living and the dead.

Georgia Montague

I read the 1st one and saw there was a 2nd and pretty much went "ughhhhh now I have to read that" because I always finish the series but I got about halfway through this and just shut it and got so annoyed.

Ashley Wendt

For some reason this series is sticking with me. I can’t say exactly what it is about the series that I love, I just really enjoy it. I do agree with other readers that the beginning of this story was a little rough but the end I flew through!

Aurora Corbett

With Burning Glass I feel like Kathryn Purdie did really well with the first book but the next two I felt just weren't as good. I was really worried that the same thing would happen here but I was WRONG. While the first book was AMAZING This one was even better and I LOVED IT. AND I CRIED SO THAT WAS GREAT!!!

Sofie

oh this literally came out today and i just finished book one. cool.

_____________

Tu ne me manques pas. Je ne te manque pas. You’re not missing from me. I’m not missing from you.

The phrase he taught me has been my mantra since I’ve come to Beau Palais. Soon I’ll be with Bastien. I won’t need Old Gallish words to hold his memory or help me visualize his sea-blue eyes and dark tousled hair. He’s alive. He has to be.

2.5 stars rounded up because I am so glad this is a duology.

plot holes plot holes plot holes. hypocrisy. evil queen is evil for no reason. idk man.

SPOILERS because I gotta get some things off my chest. 

SERIOUS SPOILERS YOU HAVE BEEN WANRED.

(view spoiler)[
First of all, for the first half of the novel, I felt like I was having deja vu. It's pretty much the exact plot of the first book.

Gates open. Something happens, gates close too soon, the dead swarm the living for 2 weeks until the gates open again at the soul bridge. Our MCs can't travel anywhere because of the vicious chained. People lose their Light. Our MCs are wholly unprepared for the ferrying at the soul bridge and shit goes wrong. In book one, Bastien is stabbed and Ailesse is kidnapped. In this book, Ailesse is Stupid (with a capital S) and falls for her mother's lie. 

The entire story is gotta sneak into the palace. oh it's not safe, gotta go to Bastien's hideout. okay now we gotta back to the palace and save Cas. oh no we're up against the chained again, I wonder where we'll be safe?! ok, back to the hideout. oh we forgot some books at the palace, guess we gotta sneak back in. oh dang, it still wasn't safe? you don't say! oh going back to the palace put Cas back in danger, which in turn puts Ailesse in danger? NO SHIT. ok, back to the hideout. 

What...happened...to the original plot of the movie (i know it's a book, this is a quote from tiktok) This think went round and round in circles until finally something new happened and Ailesse gets sucked into the underworld.

Which... wtf. Ailesse really fell for her mother's fake sincerity and promises? Even Sabine saw through it. all you need to do is touch my hand and i'll teach you how to break the soul bond. it's like Ailesse just conveniently forgot that her mother's original bargain called for Ailesse's life. This whole thing made no sense?!!?!? Why would Odiva "sacrifice" herself to the underworld and then just... trick her daughter into switching places? What was the purpose??? Ailesse was practically about to enter the Underworld gates ON HER OWN at the end of book one and Odiva ran into the gates herself to stop her. so???? 

Her plan made 0 sense, too. Give Tyrus unchained souls, kill her own daughter, get her lover back. Okay, fine. But then apparently the bargain isn't complete in book 2, and now Odiva still needs to funnel ALL unchained souls from Paradise? Bring the afterlife together? I thought Odiva was just giving Tyrus unchained souls in book 1 to try and appease Tyrus and not have to kill her own daughter? Oh but actually, suddenly she doesn't just want her love back, she wants to rule the fucking world. WUT. I can (grudgingly) accept soul-deep love as a motivation, but Odiva's quest for power made her lose ALL the humanity that kind of made her a faceted villain.

SO MANY PLOT HOLES.

And the plagues!! It was established in book 1 that the recent plague wasn't actually sickness, but rather, the chained sucking the literal life out of people because the Ferrying ceremony was cut short. But here, everyone, even the bone criers, make it seem like there was a plague and the chained fiasco? I DON'T GET IT.

AND THEN WHEN THE GOOD GUYS FINALLY WIN, AILESSE LETS HER AWFUL MOTHER AND ODIVA'S AWFUL LOVER GO TO PARADISE?!?!?!? IS THERE NO JUSTICE?!?!

 (hide spoiler)]

This book was a bloody mess. I got what Purdie was going for - an epic tale of desire vs. duty, loyalty vs. righteousness, sisterly love vs. motherly love. It could have been great if it wasn't so confined to the same 3 settings and crude villain motivations. 

The best part of the story was Sabine, who grows into her role as matroné of the Lauress, who must resist the doubts cast on her from her clan and her own grace bones, who must shed her own insecurities of being second to Ailesse in everything including love. The unwavering support between her and Ailesse was refreshing, especially in YA, and especially because for a few chapters, I honestly thought Purdie was setting her up to be a new villain. 

Anyway, that's my rant. Read this if you can stand it.

Lorelai Champion

it was definitely not as good as the first however it was good to see Sabine finding herself and Bastien coming to peace with what happened to his father

Diana Armenta 

When I finished the first book I couldn't wait for the next one, but if I'm being honest I had a really hard time getting through this book, especially in the beginning. The reason is that Ailesse was being a complete jackass and Sabine wanted to be her sister, the only one that I like completely was Bastien. I really like the end of the book though.

Gemma

I thought this series was cute in a stabby way and the ending was predictable but how the final battle was depicted was *chef kiss*

Viktoria A

Catarina

Andrada Nane

Narrated by: Fiona Hardingham, Alex Wyndham, and Billie Fulford-Brown. // Ailesse and her friends change the afterlife in the gripping conclusion to the fantasy duology that began with Bone Crier’s Moon from New York Times bestselling author Kathryn Purdie—perfect for fans of Stephanie Garber and Roshani Chokshi. Love is a matter of life and death. Bone Criers have been ferrying the dead into the afterlife for centuries, a dangerous duty only possible with the powers they gain from sacrificing their amourés, the men destined to love them and die. But Bone Criers Ailesse and Sabine—along with Ailesse’s love, Bastien—are working to chart their own course and rewrite the rules of the afterlife. If they don’t break the soul bond between Ailesse and her amouré, she could die—just as Bastien’s father did. Sabine struggles to maintain her authority as matrone of her famille—the role always destined for her sister—even as she fights to control the violent jackal power within her. Bastien is faced with a new dilemma as the spirits of the Underworld threaten the souls of his friends—and his father. Ailesse attempts to resist her mother’s siren song as she’s drawn into her own version of the Underworld. How will she save her friends once she’s cut off from their world? This pulse-pounding follow-up to Bone Crier’s Moon is a story of love, sisterhood, and determination as three friends find the courage and power to shatter the boundary between the living and the dead.

Nicole Salcedo &
Bone Crier's Dawn by Kathryn Purdie

Reviews

Highlights

Join the club

Nicole Salcedo &Bone Crier's Dawn by Kathryn Purdie

Reviews

Highlights

Join the club

Nicole Salcedo &
Bone Crier's Dawn by Kathryn Purdie