small formal note for myself that this is the first time ive read omniscient first-person pov (& critically this could be mined till the cows come home) but really the point is that this is possibly the most beautiful book i’ve ever read

I remember liking it but most of the details are fuzzy now.

truly astounding to me that this book could have been called bitter when it is a determinedly doubtless portrayal of far-reaching and unshakeable love. tish and fonny are so dear to me that it makes my heart hurt

fucking beautiful

one thing about james baldwin is that he’s going to ruin your life w his storytelling. i’m in awe what a brilliant man

Speechless. Baldwin's perfectly blends love and hardship, poetry and social critique, color and feeling.

Wow. When you feel grateful to having had read something. We read the book and watched the film, which is sort of its own animal, in our book club podcast

There is no doubt that James Baldwin is a great writer. Amazing. His talent lies in the way that he can use words to convey the depth of the human spirit. The strength and defeat and hope that anyone can have. Especially the love.

completamente obcecada por james baldwin no segundo livro lido. saindo daqui, vou correndo procurar os outros além de transcrições, entrevistas, audios TUDO sobre esse homem. que historia lindíssima sobre amor, medo, injustiça.. tantos assuntos importantes desde pautas raciais e de racismo dentro da própria família à fanatismo religioso e violência policial, social, institucional. tudo escrito com muita ternura, muita sensibilidade. não é novidade o quanto james era a frente do seu tempo mas nesse livro é como se isso ficasse mais claro ainda. foi publicado nos anos 70, mas tudo TUDO é tão atual que poderia facilmente passar por um livro contemporâneo. fiquei um bom tempinho tentando processar o final e a principio achei melancólico mas, pensando não só no final e sim na trajetoria toda, minha interpretação mudou. creio que depois de nos passar tanta garra, tanto poder em forma de família, em forma de tish, em forma de fonny, eu acredito mesmo que a única coisa que aquele final nos transmite é: esperança. o futuro é incerto mesmo e ainda lhes faltava muitas garantias, mas naquele momento a esperança era a maior certeza que eles tinham. obrigada james baldwin.

Stunning. Powerful. Delicate. Breathtaking.

james baldwin put the feeling of love, sorrow, anger, all of it into words. i’m a puddle of tears.

I love this book. I cherish Baldwin’s words and his mind. I am amazed at how much in this story I’m hearing his voice through an authentic voice of Tish. It was a quick read, written so profoundly from root to tip. At some point I had a thought how not only the content of the book but also it’s appearance depicts the systematic racism and prison system in America perfectly. The discreet look of it, the slimness, seeing it amongst hundreds of other books, you wouldn’t notice it all or maybe you would, only briefly. The same goes for every POC affected by the oppression in that country, both then and now, unless you really see them, unless you look for them, you wouldn’t notice them. You’ll only briefly pass them, but you have the privilege to not see what’s right in front of you. Baldwin wrote the love between Tish and Fonny amazingly. Not only that, the love between family, all its twisted ways; he showed it to us. Black love, black families, black men, black women. I loved Baldwin navigating the love between a woman and a man in an honest way, without restraint. He certainly knew how to represent both the good and the bad. I found the ending accurate. The openness of it holds much more than we think; it gives us hope and reality at the same time. I will think about Beale Street forever. It makes me think of a lot of things. Open Water, Moonlight.

(4.5 stars) incredibly emotional, beautifully written. I'll definitely try to read more my Baldwin.

No thoughts I have tried to gather about this book feel like they do it justice. You must read it for yourself and feel it for yourself.

So, so good. The second James Baldwin book I read in as many weeks. I thought about this book for days after.

Beautiful & heart-wrenching

3.5. I had to read this for a class, and I think the fact that I didn't care for the class and the professor may have colored how I enjoyed this book. Baldwin does convey the emotions of the characters well, and by extension demonstrates very lucidly how systemic racism affects people very personally. Still, at points it felt a bit heavy-handed, or rather, Baldwin's "point" felt a bit more transparent that would be ideal. Ultimately it's well-crafted, but there's just something about it that left me a bit colder than I'd hoped.

This was my first time reading Baldwin, and it not only reminded me why I enjoy classics so much, but also there are thousands of others that I haven't gotten my grubby little hands on yet. Classics challenge me, in the best possible ways: intellectually and emotionally. This is grim, distressing, and above all else, a reminder.

The most relevant book I've read recently is Jacqueline Woodson's Red to the Bone. The latter was a more fluid read, even with the multi-generational presentation. But "Beale Street" was more raw. More real-life. And I wish there was a Part Two to Tish and Fonny's story. A great book (and I hope the movie is as good). More James Baldwin has been added to my ever-growing list of authors.

It was okay. Books written in the 70-80’s have a peculiar choice of words & sentence structure... idk. The story was okay, didn’t bore me but didn’t intrigue me to read further either. However, I am glad I read this one

Powerful, harrowing, brutally honest, beautiful, terrifying. Baldwin’s writing is on a level of its own. This should absolutely be required reading for all students. It’s a real, truthful look at America, at the racism that runs too deeply in this country’s systems, and the love and hope that, against all odds, persists.

James Baldwin was an amazing writer with the best voices in literature, whenever I start a work of his, I am just taken away into the character's world. This book has some of most beatiful imagery and pacing I have read, the characters are great and full raw emotion. I think Baldwin understood the concept of love in such a beautiful and raw way, it's just one of the best books ever written.

This was my first introduction to James Baldwin, and I was captivated from the first page on. Baldwin's prose is not only stunning, but also feels effortless. If Beale Street Could Talk is unapologetically black in its most pure and brutal form: exploring themes of systematic racism, anti-Blackness and mass incarceration, but also strong familial relationships, empathy and passionate, all-encompassing love. All of this is done in a sober, sometimes harsh way (especially to the white eye), and that's exactly why I love it. There's no beating around the bush - Baldwin tells it how it is, and in the case of Black Americans - especially in the 70s - it isn't pretty. Voices such as Baldwin's are essential in literature, whether his stories serve as a source of relatability or confrontation.

Ok amazing book.... but I needed an ending. Not an optimistic thought. Everyone in the fam had his back as they should. Very strong powerful family so with them fighting with him it’s implied that he gets a happy ending. But does he? I need answers for real.