Reviews
Insanely hilarious and a very telling analysis of race as a concept from a 1920s perspective. Larsen is subtle but generous with details.
Here, Larsen invites in questions of solidarity, race and feeling. She asks what it costs for a black women to find satiety in a world that wants her starved, all while being absolutely hilarious. Read it!
** spoiler alert ** There’s so much negativity towards white passing people and how they used their light skin to ensure they’re safety, but it has to be jealously and colorism that influences that. They could not choose if they were white passing, and they chose to use that privilege to make sure they wouldn’t be hurt. Yes, it sucks that not everybody has that same privilege, but I’m all for people doing what they need to do to live. Also, the way that fetishization was described was absolutely perfect.
4.5 stars. I listened to this as an audiobook and absolutely loved it.
Great insight into the struggle of race identity and how each person deals with that.
A really important shirt story, including conversations about race and sexuality. For an assignment I read this while looking through a queer theoretical lens, which provides a unique perspective to the story. Larsen's storytelling is unique, lots of interesting dialogue and structure to the story. I think the most interesting aspect is the idea of Irene being an unreliable narrator, leaving details out and leading the reader down her path of delusion and confusion.
felt underdeveloped, unfinished, lazy. unrealized potential.
2.5 stars This novel serves a good purpose to bring a discussion about racial passing that's common back in it times and looking at the exploration of race, identity, and relationships. However, I just have a thing with classics and say that it hasn't grabbed my attention a lot.
A bit more dramatic at the end than I may have wanted. But the book discussed some great ideas on race, class and gender.
Such elegant writing
“To see Clare is to experience her” - this quote is a tribute to the beautiful way with words this author has. This story starts out with so much potential, tackling race, social status and sacrifices one makes to uphold the lives they’ve built. However I was disappointed by the turn this book made in the last 30 pages to a (for me) let-down by turning this story into one of jealousy, betrayal and insecurity. There is many incredible places this book could have gone but instead it ends with the unoriginality of fear and insecurity turned murder. Have to say I expected more for this ending.
here’s my rhetorical analysis: the title “passing” eludes to the idea of passing, which really makes for a pretty decent book.
here’s my rhetorical analysis: the title “passing” eludes to the idea of passing, which really makes for a pretty decent book.
I read this for university and I ... really, really liked it. It's nice when your school texts suck you in so much it's like you're not even doing schoolwork. This was incredibly thought-provoking and such easy reading compared to some other modernist texts. The amount of ground Larsen was able to cover in such a short book was truly a feat. I really enjoyed the themes Larsen chose to explore and following her characters as they struggled with their identities and situations. While at times the subject matter was hard to read, it was also extremely compelling and thought-provoking. Part two was definitely my favourite but parts one and three were great also. Written during the Harlem-Renaissance, Passing follows Irene Radfield and Clare Kendry, childhood friends who have a chance encounter as adults in a Chiacago tea shop. Although these two black women grew up together they're now living completely different lives - Irene lives with her dark-skinned husband and two sons in Harlem where she is enmeshed in the Harlem cultural scene. Clare has been passing as white for 12 years, has become estranged from black culture and now lives with her white supremacist husband and their daughter. This chance encounter forces the two women to examine their lives, and how they could have been living had they not made the choices they did. This was a truly interesting introspection of life in Harlem, New York during the 1920's and the issues - whether they be race, gender or sexuality, that were facing communities. I was also living for the queer subtext. The ending, while abrupt, left me with lots to ponder, which I kind of like. This really was such a great read, I enjoyed it so much and it left me with so many interesting thoughts. I'm really glad it got assigned!
here’s my rhetorical analysis: the title “passing” eludes to the idea of passing, which really makes for a pretty decent book.
I read this for a class this semester, Social Deviance & the Law, and it was so thought provoking that I wanted to share on here. All my people of color: if you could flip a switch and be white, and people would see and treat you like a white person, starting tomorrow, would you do it? Even if it means leaving your prior cultural and racial identity behind? Would you give it all up to be part of the racial majority in America? Passing by Nella Larsen is a small but powerful book that breaches the ever-relevant topics of identity, public perception, race, racial privilege, breaking social norms, and the harmful rigidity of social classes and caste-ism. Besides all the important underlying themes, it’s a quick little thriller with a shocking turn of events in the end. Spend an afternoon or lazy morning with this book and I promise it’ll have you thinking about race and American society for a while. It felt especially poignant and powerful in this era of wrongful discrimination and persecution of black people by the police and Asians and Pacific Islanders by violent and hateful citizens. For more bookish photos, reviews and updates follow me on instagram @concerningnovels.
rebecca hall’s take on this stunning stunning work by nella larsen is now on netflix! go see it, because i thought it was near perfect.
3.75 Short but impactful. I listened to this one on audio. I think I might have enjoyed it a smidge more if I read it, just to be able to sit in the language a bit more, especially since it gave a bit of gothic romance vibes. Interesting to read this after Vanishing Half to see the difference in how those that are passing, Clare (in this book) and Stella (Vanishing Half), treat other African Americans. Liked that this book gave a lot of air to breathe and interpret, like what really is going on with Irene, Brian, and Clare? What really happened with Clare? What is reality and what is simply fear manifesting in paranoia for Irene?
C'était intéressant mais j'aurai préfèré avoir le point de vue de Claire. Je nai pas spécialement apprécié le personnage de Irène et j'aurai aimé avoir le ressenti et les motivations profondes de Claire sur son choix de vie.
read this for my class “black identities” and actually enjoyed it
3,5
LOVE larsen's writing - how it just flows, how she describes things, her vocabulary, plot development (although the ending was a little sudden!) ... literally couldn't stop turning the pages. its hard to believe this was a book written for 1920s america (+a book i definitely wouldn't have picked up on my own volition); truly a timeless piece that has many lessons even today's america needs to take heed. larsen gives us two rather unlikeable female protagonists, irene and clare, to explore notions of race, self-deception, and self-rejection; how much of you is your race, and can they even be evaluated independently of each other? i wonder how the story might have been different had we gotten more of clare's part of the story, but otherwise, a lot packed in 200 pages and a great read!
Deeply uncomfortable, with flawed characters, this book is a brief glimpse into the experience of passing in the 1920’s. Thought provoking and memorable a book I am glad I stumbled across.
"Passing" is a fascinating first-hand view into the Harlem Renaissance that has stood the test of time nearly 100 years later. Irene is a light-skinned Black woman who lives the best of lives in Harlem among the elite of the area, working for Black charity balls and events. Clare re-enters her life from childhood, but as equally light-skinned, passes for a White woman married to a devout racist. Irene is frustrated, angry, and annoyed with Clare's presence -- as well as attracted to her as well. Irene envies Clare's freeness to live as a White woman, while Clare admires Irene's abilities to live true to herself. The book is a battle among all these emotions. A fantastic book.