More than anything, the Toothless Fairy wants to have a friend she can play with, but she feels unloveable as she has only one tooth. She is lonely and sad and feels she can't make friends, because she will scare them away. When Halloween comes around, she notices that the kids are not afraid of all the scary costumes out there and she realizes, maybe this is her chance to find a way to make a friend. She comes up with a brilliant plan and that is how a new Halloween tradition begins.